Last Update: 2008/04/09
Capabilities
Things CiteGenie does not do
Capabilities
No. Westlaw has a feature that provides some rudamentary citing functions, but it doesn't put the cite in the clipboard for you, it requires multiple steps, and it doesn't handle citations for footnotes and many other features of CiteGenie. CiteGenie will give you a correctly formatted Bluebook-standard citation much more reliabily that Westlaw. In addition, the configuration options of CiteGenie allow you to customize citations to the format proper for your court, such as "California Style" citations with the date parenthetical at the beginning of the citation.
CiteGenie handles multi-page quotes and will give the correct pinpoint pages using standard notion.
CiteGenie handles footnotes and will give the correct pinpoint page and footnote using standard notion.
Alas, nothing done by a computer is going to be perfect. CiteGenie is good, and in our testing provides correct citations in almost all cases. However, there are some situations where it does stumble. Of course, humans don't always get citations right either. I read a lot of briefs, and in my experience, CiteGenie is better than a lot of humans. It is an automated tool, and with any automated tool, you need to apply your own expertiese to your use of it.
Yes, that is a configurable option.
Yes, that is a configurable option.
Yes, in most cases. However, because the text is coming from an HTML source, only sources that understand pasting of rich text from an HTML source will accept the pasted text with formatting. Microsoft Word does this. Wordperfect does not, without some help. To get formatting when pasting into Wordperfect, you have to enable GenieMacro on the "Advanced Options" tab in the CiteGenie configuration screen.
If the original document had some text bold, underlined, or italicized, that formatting will usually carry over when you paste from CiteGenie, as long as the program you are pasting into accepts HTML formatting codes. Microsoft Word does. Wordperfect does not, without some help. To get formatting when pasting into Wordperfect, you have to enable GenieMacro on the "Advanced Options" tab in the CiteGenie configuration screen.
In many cases, yes. Most states court citations are handled by the default formatting. CiteGenie is configurable and canproduce citations formatted for the specific rules in several states, such as putting the parenthetical date up front and indicating the appellate disctrict or region for decsions from the state's appellate courts.
Things CiteGenie does not do
CiteGenie does not know if the case you are quoting from has already been cited earlier in your brief and could be cited with a shorter form.
CiteGenie does not know if you will paste the quotation at the beginning of a sentance or not, so it is unable to know if the first letter of the quotation should be converted to uppercase or lowercase.
Some state courts (such as Texas) have rules for briefs submitted in that state, which require special citation forms for that state's court cases. These sometimes require writ history and additional information in the court name. CiteGenie cannot do the writ history, since the writ history is not part of the opinion in Westlaw (and thus is is not in your browser's memory that CiteGenie can query).
CiteGenie can not identify the author's name for law journal publications in Westlaw or Lexis.